PMO In RTI Reply Rejects Charge That PM Modi’s Yoga Day Fitness Video Cost Rs 35 Lakh

New Delhi: No expenditure was incurred on the making of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s fitness video in June, the PMO has said in an RTI reply, according to a PTI report.

On June 13, a week before the Yoga day, Modi posted his fitness video on Twitter in which he was seen stretching on a rock, walking barefoot on a narrow path and doing yoga, wearing a black jogging dress. The PM had released the video days after accepting a fitness challenge from Indian cricket captain Virat Kohli.

Congress MP Shashi Tharoor had alleged that Rs 35 lakh was spent on making of the video, but the claim was rejected by the government.

“No expenditure has been incurred on filming of the video posted by Shri Narendra Modi. The video was filmed at the prime minister’s residence,” the PMO said replying to an RTI query.

It said the videography was done by the cameraman of the PMO and that nothing has been procured for the video.

“Here are moments from my morning exercises. Apart from Yoga, I walk on a track inspired by the ‘panchtatvas’ or five elements of nature – Prithvi, Jal, Agni, Vayu, Aakash. This is extremely refreshing and rejuvenating. I also practice breathing exercises. #HumFitTohIndiaFit”,” the prime minister had tweeted along with the video.

In the video, the PM was seen doing the exercises and yoga, wearing a black jogging dress. He was also seen balancing himself while walking on a narrow, circular track.

Ahead of the Yoga Day celebrations, a campaign titled “#HumFitTohIndiaFit” (If we are fit, India is fit) was launched and Sports Minister Minister Rajyavardhan Rathore had said that Modi was the inspiration for it.

Source: PTI

PM Modi’s Rs 35 lakh Yoga Shoot: Female staff at Indiascoops.com threatened with RAPE, editor threatened with DEATH

Over the last 4 days, IndiaScoops.com has been bombed with thousands of vulgar, threatening and hate emails.  On the first two days ie., 1st and 2nd July, the emails were restricted to only threatening and hate messages, however since yesterday evening, our female staff – we are a 90 per cent female team – have got emails threatening them with molestation and rape. Some of the emails are so vulgar, abusive and sexually descriptive in nature that it is impossible to even try to read them. Other emails seem to be sent by females – female-to-female sexual harassment seems to be the new harassment tool used by certain sections of Indian society.

Many of the emails are quite similar in text and content. It looks like the senders have copy-pasted a standard sample email,  just making few changes in a couple of words here and there. This clearly shows a pattern or a concerted campaign towards IndiaScoops.com  to silence and shut us down.

As reported earlier, such was the impact of the spamming that both the web-server and mail servers crashed 8-10 times on 2 and 3 July, after the post went viral.

Also Read: Rs 35 lakh: Cost of PM Narendra Modi’s Yoga Videos and Photo Shoot?

This website which first published a post alleging that PM Narendra Modi‘s team could have possibly spent Rs 35 lakh on the shooting, editing, making and circulation of the International Yoga Day Fitness Challenge video

Several attempts were made to hack into the web-server using DDoS methods and bring the site down. Other hackers tried to using automated password-guessing software to crack the passwords of the site and break into the main database.

Some of the emails threaten that IndiaScoops.com‘s editor and editorial team will meet with the same fate as journalist and thinker Gauri Lankesh who was murdered last year. The website has submitted printouts of the threatening and vulgar emails as well as the hacking attempt logs to the Mumbai police who have started looking into the matter.

Also Read: Indiascoops.com editor threatened with death, site bombed with thousands of vulgar, threatening and hate emails

The report which was published based on unconfirmed reports from the PMO, very clearly stated so in its content. However, the post went viral after it was shared on social media by several well-known politicians with a huge online following. Union Minister of Youth Affairs and Sports Rajyavardhan Singh Rathore on Monday evening took to Twitter to refute the claim made by IndiaScoops.com and said that no money was spent for Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s fitness video for the viral ‘Fitness Challenge’ on Twitter.

However, IndiaScoops.com in a rebuttal said it stood by its story, but never claimed in its post that the Rs 35 lakh figure was gospel truth, as it was not obtained through an RTI enquiry but was based on hearsay from an unverified source. “The figure could be incorrect and maybe could be much more,” the editor said in another post.

On the micro-blogging site, Rathore took a jibe at Congress leader Shashi Tharoor after he shared the IndiaScoops.com article alleging Rs 35 lakh was spent to shoot the video.

‘Not surprised Mr @ShashiTharoor, falsehoods is your substitute 4 facts. No money was spent for PM’s fitness video. It was recorded by PMO videographer. This article is based on ‘solid proof’ of hearsay. And I assure you sir, not a single ‘lamb’ was sacrificed for the video, let alone 35,’

Also Read: No money spent on PM Modi’s Yoga video: I&B Minister Rajyavardhan Rathore

To this Tharoor replied: “Delighted to hear no lambs were sacrificed. But the people of India have been fleeced nonetheless, by the Govt’s 20 crore expenditure of taxpayer money on publicity as a substitute for achievement.”

Earlier in the day, Tharoor had tweeted the post in his own trademark inimitable tongue-in-cheek style, claiming that the Centre spent Rs 20 crore on advertisements on International Yoga Day’20 crore rupees in ads for #YogaDay, 35 lambs for @PMOIndia’s fitness video! Disgraceful. This government is all about smoke and mirrors. Hype is their substitute for hope — the hopes they have destroyed,’ Tharoor tweeted.

The ‘Fitness Challenge’ was started by Rathore on Twitter as part of the ‘Hum Fit Toh India Fit’ campaign on May 22.While taking up star cricketer Virat Kohli’s ‘Fitness Challenge’, the Prime Minister on June 13 shared a video of him performing yoga on Twitter.

Rs 35 lakh Modi Yoga Video: Indiascoops.com editor threatened with death, site bombed with thousands of vulgar, threatening and hate emails

This website which first published a post alleging that PM Narendra Modi‘s team could have possibly spent Rs 35 lakh on the shooting, editing, making and circulation of the International Yoga Day Fitness Challenge video has been bombed with thousands of vulgar, threatening and hate emails over the last two days. Such was the impact of the spamming that both the web-server and mail servers crashed 8-10 times on 2 and 3 July, after the post went viral.

Also Read: Female staff at Indiascoops.com threatened with RAPE, editor with DEATH

Several attempts were made to hack into the web-server using DDoS methods and bring the site down. Other hackers tried to using automated password-guessing software to crack the passwords of the site and break into the main database.

Some of the emails threaten that IndiaScoops.com‘s editor and editorial team will meet with the same fate as journalist and thinker Gauri Lankesh who was murdered last year. The website has submitted printouts of the threatening and vulgar emails as well as the hacking attempt logs to the Mumbai police who have started looking into the matter.

Also Read: Rs 35 lakh: Cost of PM Narendra Modi’s Yoga Videos and Photo Shoot?

The report which was published based on unconfirmed reports from the PMO, very clearly stated so in its content. However, the post went viral after it was shared on social media by several well-known politicians with a huge online following. Union Minister of Youth Affairs and Sports Rajyavardhan Singh Rathore on Monday evening took to Twitter to refute the claim made by IndiaScoops.com and said that no money was spent for Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s fitness video for the viral ‘Fitness Challenge’ on Twitter.

However, IndiaScoops.com in a rebuttal said it stood by its story, but never claimed in its post that the Rs 35 lakh figure was gospel truth, as it was not obtained through an RTI enquiry but was based on hearsay from an unverified source. “The figure could be incorrect and maybe could be much more,” the editor said in another post.

On the micro-blogging site, Rathore took a jibe at Congress leader Shashi Tharoor after he shared the IndiaScoops.com article alleging Rs 35 lakh was spent to shoot the video.

‘Not surprised Mr @ShashiTharoor, falsehoods is your substitute 4 facts. No money was spent for PM’s fitness video. It was recorded by PMO videographer. This article is based on ‘solid proof’ of hearsay. And I assure you sir, not a single ‘lamb’ was sacrificed for the video, let alone 35,’

Also Read: No money spent on PM Modi’s Yoga video: I&B Minister Rajyavardhan Rathore

To this Tharoor replied: “Delighted to hear no lambs were sacrificed. But the people of India have been fleeced nonetheless, by the Govt’s 20 crore expenditure of taxpayer money on publicity as a substitute for achievement.”

Earlier in the day, Tharoor had tweeted the post in his own trademark inimitable tongue-in-cheek style, claiming that the Centre spent Rs 20 crore on advertisements on International Yoga Day’20 crore rupees in ads for #YogaDay, 35 lambs for @PMOIndia’s fitness video! Disgraceful. This government is all about smoke and mirrors. Hype is their substitute for hope — the hopes they have destroyed,’ Tharoor tweeted.

The ‘Fitness Challenge’ was started by Rathore on Twitter as part of the ‘Hum Fit Toh India Fit’ campaign on May 22.While taking up star cricketer Virat Kohli’s ‘Fitness Challenge’, the Prime Minister on June 13 shared a video of him performing yoga on Twitter.

No money spent on PM Modi’s Yoga video, clarifies Sports and I&B Minister Rajyavardhan Rathore

Union Minister of Youth Affairs and Sports Rajyavardhan Singh Rathore on Monday claimed that no money was spent for Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s fitness video for the viral ‘Fitness Challenge’ on Twitter.

On the micro-blogging site, Rathore took a jibe at Congress leader Shashi Tharoor after he shared an article alleging Rs 35 lakh was spent to shoot the video.

Also Read: Female staff at Indiascoops.com threatened with RAPE, editor with DEATH

“Not surprised Mr @ShashiTharoor, falsehoods is your substitute 4 facts. No money was spent for PM’s fitness video. It was recorded by PMO videographer. This article is based on ‘solid proof’ of hearsay. And I assure you sir, not a single ‘lamb’ was sacrificed for the video, let alone 35,” Rathore wrote.

Earlier in the day, Tharoor tweeted a report claiming that the Centre spent Rs 20 crore on advertisements on International Yoga Day.

Also Read: Rs 35 lakh: Cost of PM Narendra Modi’s Yoga Videos and Photo Shoot?

“20 crore rupees in ads for #YogaDay, 35 lambs for @PMOIndia’s fitness video! Disgraceful. This government is all about smoke and mirrors. Hype is their substitute for hope — the hopes they have destroyed,” Tharoor tweeted.

The ‘Fitness Challenge’ was started by Rathore on Twitter as part of the ‘Hum Fit Toh India Fit’ campaign on May 22.

While taking up star cricketer Virat Kohli’s ‘Fitness Challenge’, the Prime Minister on June 13 shared a video of him performing yoga on Twitter.

Source: ANI

Rs 35 lakh: Cost of PM Narendra Modi’s Yoga Videos and Photo Shoot, AYUSH Ministry spent Rs 20 crores on Ads for International Yoga Day

Rs 35 lakh: Yes that’s the cost the PMO spent only on Narendra Modi’s Yoga videos and photo shoot for International Yoga Day June 21, 2018, which went viral all over the world. And yes, these are conservative figures only!

This does not include the costs for the animated yoga videos where a cartoon character resembling Modi is shown demonstrating various asanas or yoga positions. The animated Modi Yoga cartoon video was made by a private party at the insistence of the BJP Media Cell. It is not known if the private party has billed the BJP for the animation, which is expected to cost at least an additional Rs 40-45 lakh. Another source told IndiaScoops.com that such animation could even cost Rs 75 to 80 lakh depending on where it is done. It is much cheaper in cities like Hyderabad, but costs double if done at a large Animation Studio in Mumbai.

Addressing the nation in his monthly radio address, ‘Mann Ki Baat‘, the Prime Minister lauded people who made the animation yoga video and shared the same too.

Also Read: Female staff at Indiascoops.com threatened with RAPE, editor with DEATH

The PMO is extremely tight-lipped about the expenses for this ‘publicity stunt’ and strict instructions have been given to PMO personnel not to discuss it even casually with friends or family. Why all this secrecy, unless the money came from some tainted source?

Officially, the PMO maintains it did not spend a single penny on this shoot  the same was corroborated by a tweet by Sports and I&B Minister Rajyavardhan Rathore on Monday evening, almost 24 hours after the original post went viral, (the post has been updated since then) who stated in his tweet that the videos and photos were shot by the in-house PMO videographer, but unofficially, PMO sources confirmed to IndiaScoops.com that the entire exercise cost over Rs 35 lakh, which was ‘donated’ or ‘sponsored’ by a third party. Nobody is however ready to share the name of the third-party and after this news went viral on social media, our PMO source has switched off his mobile phone or probably got himself a new number.

IndiaScoops.com tried to contact the PMO for an official comment or clarification, but were stone-walled. It now seems a huge part of this amount was spent in circulating and disseminating the video and not on the shoot per say, and getting media houses and Tv channels to run it during prime time.

IndiaScoops.com before publishing this post on Saturday, made attempts to contact the Sports Minister Rajyavardhan Rathore for comment, but there was no response, possibly because it was a Saturday and after working hours.

Also Read: No money spent on PM Modi’s Yoga video: I&B Minister Rajyavardhan Rathore

Another RTI query had revealed that the government in 2015 spent Rs 15.87 crore on SMS messages alone to promote Yoga Day ahead of 21 June.

While the PMO source has denied that the amount mentioned above for the yoga shoot was spent from the purse of the Public Exchequer this year, sources indicate that the expense involved in shooting and editing the videos was “sponsored” by a private party whose identity is unknown. The videos were shot over 3 days and then edited. Besides the actual video and photo shoot, there was a ‘making video’ also made. Similarly, there was a professional photo shoot done, which was released publicly only after editing and touch up.

Was this amount paid by the BJP party? The answer may never be known.

Narendra-Modi-fitness-challenge-1
Expenses incurred for this photo and video shoot are around Rs 35 lakh? Where did the money come from?

Modi posted his fitness video on Twitter which shows him meditating, walking on a track inspired by five elements of nature, and doing yoga exercises.

The AYUSH Ministry spent over Rs 20 crores this year for the fourth edition of the International Yoga Day, reports NDTV. This figure was obtained by RTI and reports were published by several mainline publications.

More than half of this amount was spent on advertisement, campaigns and special programmes across various media platforms like television, newspapers, journals and social media.

Also Read: Indiascoops.com editor threatened with death, site bombed with thousands of vulgar, threatening and hate emails

The government also spent on accessories like T-shirts, caps, mats for the participants of mass yoga sessions, including the ones organised by Indian missions abroad.

The Rs. 20 crore budget did not include expenditure incurred on security and other overheads. Nor did it include expenditure by various state governments. Several NGOs were roped in to mobilize participants and the expenses spent by these NGOs is obviously not included in these figures. Media reports claim that nearly one lakh yoga enthusiasts were roped in by NGOs for demonstrations in Delhi alone and the logistics alone could have cost not less than Rs 2 crore.

RTI data had revealed that Ayush had spent Rs 32.5 crores last year on International Yoga Day. This year’s budget was lower but the government did not want a confrontation with the opposition on the scale of celebrations.

“There are 193 countries in United Nations and except Libya and Yemen, yoga day is being celebrated in all the countries,” External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj had said.

The Mass Yoga demonstration at Rajpath in 2015 had cost Rs 7.59 crore. Expenses for the International Conference on Yoga was Rs 1.83 crore The Ministry of External Affairs spent Rs 8 crore for related advertising and promotion activities in various Indian Missions across the world.

Apart from these, the Council for Research in Yoga & Naturopathy (CCRYN) provided assistance of up to 1 lakh rupees per district for the celebration, a total of Rs 6.7 crore. The Morarji Desai National Institute of Yoga (MDNIY) produced a film and booklets on Yoga with an expenditure of Rs 34.8 lakh.

narendra-modi-yoga-day
Expenses incurred for this photo and video shoot are around Rs 35 lakh? Where did the money come from?

According to information provided by the Ministry of AYUSH under RTI, the vendor for managing the event at Rajpath was M/s. Arch Concept Pvt. Ltd. The vendor was paid a total of Rs 3.67 crore for the arrangements, reports Factly.

While it is not clear where the yoga mats were procured from, with reports claiming that the mats were purchases in bulk from China, the RTI reply suggests that the vendor Arch Concept procured 36000 yoga mats. The total expenditure (including tax) for these 36000 Yoga Mats was Rs 1.02 crore.

Meanwhile, an RTT filed by an Aam Aadmi Party activist has revealed that Rs 8.5 crore was spent just to advertise the Prime Minister’s ‘mann ki baat‘ radio address.

A RTI filed by AAP activist Mulk Raj Anand last year revealed that the government has spent over Rs 8.5 crore from January to 29 July – a period of six months, on newspaper advertisements to promote the Prime Minister’s radio address, reports the Indian Express.

Congress leader Sanjay Nirupam took a dig at Modi for posting a video on fitness challenge and wondered how many days did he “waste” on making the video.

modi-yoga-videos-costs-expenses-shoot
Expenses incurred for this photo and video shoot are around Rs 35 lakh? Where did the money come from?

“In last 4 years i.e 1475 days, PM Modi spent 800 days on public rallies, more than 150 days on foreign trips. But he attended Parliament only for 19 days. God knows how many days he wasted on his Yoga videos?” Nirupam, who is the president of Mumbai Pradesh Congress Committee, said.

He also passed on the fitness challenge to Karnataka Chief Minister H D Kumaraswamy, table tennis player Manika Batra and IPS officers, especially those above 40 years of age.

The prime minister’s one-and-a-half minute video came nearly a month after he accepted the fitness challenge thrown by Indian cricket team skipper Virat Kohli.

While posting the video Modi said, “Apart from Yoga, I walk on a track inspired by the Panchtatvas or 5 elements of nature – Prithvi, Jal, Agni, Vayu, Aakash. This is extremely refreshing and rejuvenating. I also practise breathing exercises.”

narendra-modi-yoga-fitness
Expenses incurred for this photo and video shoot are around Rs 35 lakh? Where did the money come from?

Wearing a black jogging outfit, Modi is seen walking on a track created around a tree, doing stretching exercise and sitting on a rock for meditation.

He is also seen balancing himself while walking on a narrow, circular track.

Update: According to a Times of India report, Sports and I&B minister Rajyavardhan Rathore on Monday evening clarified via a post on Twitter that no money was spent on the photo shoot. The TOI report states Rathore  ‘slammed’ Congress leader Shashi Tharoor and said that no money was spent on the PM Modi’s fitness video. He claimed in his tweet that the video was shot by the PMO videographer.

The Union minister was responding to Tharoor’s tweet which cited a media report alleging Rs 35 lakh was spent to shoot the video. Quoting the tweet, TOI says, the I&B minister took a dig at Tharoor’s mention of “lambs” in the tweet and said, “And I assure you, sir, not a single ‘lamb’ was sacrificed for the vid, let alone 35!”

IndiaScoops.com responds: We,  like most other Indians do not expect the PMO to admit to these expenses, particularly after such a furor on social media. In the post above, we have clearly stated that these were unofficial expenses, incurred by a third party. Which means, they do not fall under RTI. Like we have said above (and in the clarification below), the story is based on inputs provided by a PMO source,  the identity of whom we unfortunately cannot reveal at this stage. We stand by our story.

Content (c) IndiaScoops.com

 

Editor’s Note & Clarification: Firstly we would like to thank all those who shared this post. After this post went viral on social media, IndiaScoops.com got several emails asking for the veracity and details of our news source.

We at IndiaScoops.com are intrigued and humored that the pro-BJP, right-wing propaganda website opindia.com has dedicated a detailed post about us. Yes, we are ready to share our “sources” with you, which our team has developed over the last 25 years and more, of being ‘real’ journalists all over India, but unfortunately, you won’t like to publish our stuff. Truth hurts, they say! 

Dear opindia.com and all the other pro-BJP, right-wing websites and their teams and owners, we have just one message for you: we may not have the ‘deep pockets’ you have. But we definitely have one thing that you will never have – we have been ‘real’ journalists even before you were born. And speaking of our ‘sources’, the real stuff is yet to come. Having said this, let us clarify, we are not anti-Modi or anti-BJP. Give us a good story and we will publish it, period!

Yes we did ‘buy’ our current FB page from someone else. Is that a crime? You guys too buy your FB ‘LIKES’, ‘Twitter Follows” and ‘YouTube Subscribers’ from Turkey, Pakistan, Bangladesh and other such places that have click farms and run automated software ‘auto-likers’ and other ‘sidey’ vendors. We all know the lot, don’t we?

There were several abusive and threatening emails (which we anyway expected), after seeing what has been happening to Cabinet Minister Sushma Swaraj.

However, we cannot reply to all emails and hence are using this space below to clarify the following queries: 

  1. This post will be updated and modified as new data is available. The Rs 35 lakh figure was given to us by our PMO source. As every journalist and editor knows, the actual identity of “sources” is sacrosanct and cannot be revealed. No matter what! So we are sorry we cannot identify or reveal the name of our PMO source.
  2. The rest of the figures quoted above in this article are all in public domain and have already been published in the past by various reputed publications and have been obtained through RTI.
  3. This is a developing story and will be updated or corrected as more information pours in. IndiaScoops.com has contacted several people associated with the Yoga Day celebrations for their input and feedback and re-confirmation of details. We will update this story as and when additional information comes in.
  4. And last, but not least, we request the PMO to kindly make public the name of the agency, photographer and cinematographer who shot the video. Give them some credit guys, you kinda entertained millions!

 

We welcome our readers (and enemies) to send us feedback to indiascoops AT gmail.com